---
title: "Case Study: Rewarding Employees Without Dilution"
url: "https://nexteralegal.com/case-studies/growth-without-dilution/"
description: "How a cash-based phantom stock plan let a fast-scaling technology firm reward and retain employees while its founder kept 100% ownership and control."
author: "Next Era Legal"
published: "2026-11-02T18:56:45.905+00:00"
updated: "2026-11-10T18:57:22.085519+00:00"
publisher: "Next Era Legal"
---

Corporate & business · A fast-scaling technology development firm

# Growth without dilution.

The company was adding headcount rapidly. The founder wanted to incentivize and retain top talent, but without diluting ownership or altering company control.

01 The situation

## Pressure to share equity, and a founder who wanted to keep it.

- **Industry:** Technology development
- **Stage:** Fast-scaling, adding headcount
- **Founder’s goal:** Retain 100% ownership
- **What we built:** A phantom stock plan

As the employee count grew, so did pressure to offer equity or stock options to key contributors. The company needed a way to share upside without surrendering equity.

1. **A founder keeping control** The founder wanted to retain 100% ownership.
2. **Equity’s complexity** Equity distribution created complexity and risk.
3. **No incentive plan** There was no existing incentive plan to align employee success with company performance.

02 Our approach

## Synthetic equity, paid in cash.

We worked closely with the founder to understand the legal, financial and cultural dimensions of the problem, then introduced a more strategic option.

### Understood the problem

We worked closely with the founder to understand the legal, financial and cultural dimensions of the problem.

### Designed a phantom stock plan

A synthetic equity model that rewards employees through cash bonuses tied to company valuation.

### Tied it to retention

Structured to align with long-term performance and retention, with no dilution and no change in the equity structure.

### Drafted and rolled it out

Plan documents drafted, and the structure integrated into the company’s internal communications.

03 What happened

## Owners in spirit, not on paper.

The company expanded to over 20 employees with high morale. Retention and performance rose without requiring equity grants, and a culture of ownership emerged, driven by strategic legal structuring.

The founder kept full control and flexibility.

The takeaway

You don’t have to give away equity to reward team members: the plan made employees feel like owners without being owners on paper, and without complicating future capital events.

04 Who handled it

## Talk to the attorneys who handled it.

Founding Partner

Eric Proos

Los Angeles · Beverly Hills office

(310) 734-4791

[Read Eric’s profile](https://nexteralegal.com/about/eric-proos/)

Founding Partner

Jeff Monahan

Miami office

(305) 686-4866

[Read Jeff’s profile](https://nexteralegal.com/about/jeff-monahan/)

Share it with your team

Passing this to a partner or your board? Send them the two-page PDF: it carries Eric’s and Jeff’s direct lines, a way to book and this page’s address.

- [Download the two-page PDF](https://nexteralegal.com/obs/assets/img/cases/sheets/growth-without-dilution.pdf)

Follow the firm

- [Next Era Legal on LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/company/nexteralegal)
- [Next Era Legal on YouTube](https://www.youtube.com/@NextEraLegal)
- [Next Era Legal on Instagram](https://www.instagram.com/NextEraLegal)
- [Next Era Legal on Facebook](https://facebook.com/NextEraLegal)
- [Next Era Legal on X](https://x.com/NextEraLegal)

**About these case studies.** Each describes one engagement and what happened in it. Results depend on the facts of each matter, and nothing here is a prediction or a guarantee about another. Clients are described by type rather than named unless they have given written consent. Nothing on this page is legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney–client relationship.

## Growth Without Dilution.

1. [1 Case Study Hub](https://nexteralegal.com/case-studies/)
2. [2 Unlocking Growth Without Capital](https://nexteralegal.com/case-studies/unlocking-growth-without-capital/)
3. *3* Growth Without Dilution
4. [4 Cross-Border Growth](https://nexteralegal.com/case-studies/cross-border-growth/)
5. [5 Compliance from Day One](https://nexteralegal.com/case-studies/compliance-from-day-one/)
6. [6 Correcting the Record](https://nexteralegal.com/case-studies/multi-tenant-acquisition-rescue/)
7. [7 Asset Protection in Action](https://nexteralegal.com/case-studies/veil-piercing-intercompany-transfers/)
8. [8 The Uninsurable Asset](https://nexteralegal.com/case-studies/high-risk-asset-rental/)
9. [9 Managing the Defense](https://nexteralegal.com/case-studies/employment-claim-litigation-management/)
10. [10 The Reciprocal Buyout Offer](https://nexteralegal.com/case-studies/reciprocal-partner-buyout/)

[Next · 4 of 10: Cross-Border Growth How a loan and operating terms were restructured so a business backed by international investors could refinance with their immigration status intact.](https://nexteralegal.com/case-studies/cross-border-growth/)

Free guide

## How to keep good people without giving away the company.

Reward your best people and keep the company yours. See which incentives your entity can actually offer, how options, restricted stock, profits interests and phantom stock compare, and what each one means for tax.

Free. Sent to your email.

Case study

## The seller's errors stalled the deal. We took it to closing.

The wrong sellers, a building they did not own, too little time to inspect. Follow how the whole file was put right and the acquisition closed.

[Or download the two-page PDF](https://nexteralegal.com/obs/assets/img/cases/sheets/multi-tenant-acquisition-rescue.pdf)

Free checklist

## How to close an LLC so it stays closed.

Walking away does not close the company. Follow the California and Texas steps in the order they must happen: approvals, debts and claims, final tax filings and the right form, so nothing is left open behind you.

Free. Sent to your email.

1. [Guide: see all 7 guides](https://nexteralegal.com/guides/#all-guides)
2. [Case study: see all 9 case studies](https://nexteralegal.com/case-studies/#cases)
3. [Checklist: see all 4 checklists](https://nexteralegal.com/checklists/#checklists)

In clients’ words

## What clients say.

Five stars Google

> “Jeff is very professional, knowledgeable, and experienced, they charge a very decent fees and they look after their clients.”

— **Emad Ebeied** Los Angeles Review

Five stars Google

> “Jeff and his team are top shelf service. I feel so grateful for his guidance and knowledge.”

— **Amber Shreve** Los Angeles Review

Five stars Google

> “Jeff is always there when you have questions. Take care of things promply. GREAT SERVICE!”

— **Ted Cotter** Los Angeles Review

Five stars Google

> “Jeff is great to work with.”

— **Andrew Barrett** Los Angeles Review

Five stars Google

> “Eric Proos at Next Era Legal is the definition of professionalism. He consistently delivers high-quality work with incredible attention to detail and a clear, strategic approach. What I appreciate most about Eric is not just his expertise,…”

— **Jacob Rixon** San Diego Review

Five stars Google

> “Eric is a wonderful person and a true professional. He's incredibly detail-oriented and a great sounding board for questions. No ask feels too big or too small, and I really appreciate how intentional and thoughtful he is. He's been a terrific resource, and I highly recommend him.”

— **Aj Johnson** San Diego Review

Five stars Google

> “I've been impressed with the team at Next Era Legal. They combine sharp legal expertise with a modern, business-first mindset. I.e., they're practical, responsive, and strategic. I highly recommend them!”

— **Jack Perkins** San Diego Review

Five stars Google

> “I highly recommend Eric and his team at Next Era Legal. Eric has a high level of understanding on how best to serve his clients and I have no reservations about referring to him.”

— **Danielle Barger** San Diego Review

Further reading

## More on equity and employee incentives.

- [Blog: SAFE vs. Convertible Note for Seed Rounds](https://nexteralegal.com/blog/safe-vs-convertible-note/)
- [Checklist: Seed Financing Instruments Checklist](https://nexteralegal.com/checklists/startup-funding/)

Also worth reading

- [Employee Incentive Plans](https://nexteralegal.com/guides/equity-compensation/)
- [Fractional General Counsel for Venture-Backed Startups](https://nexteralegal.com/who-we-serve/venture-backed-startups/)

Eight locations, one team Typically replies the same business day

- [Los Angeles Beverly Hills Office (310) 734-4791 Mon–Fri](https://nexteralegal.com/locations/los-angeles/)
- [Orange County Newport Beach Office (949) 209-4184 Mon–Fri](https://nexteralegal.com/locations/orange-county/)
- [San Diego University City Office (619) 323-3445 Mon–Fri](https://nexteralegal.com/locations/san-diego/)
- [San Francisco SoMa Office (650) 374-1337 Mon–Fri](https://nexteralegal.com/locations/san-francisco/)
- [Houston Uptown Office (713) 255-2098 Mon–Fri](https://nexteralegal.com/locations/houston/)
- [Metro Detroit Town Center Office (313) 887-4788 Mon–Fri](https://nexteralegal.com/locations/metro-detroit/)
- [Washington, DC K Street Office Phone coming soon Mon–Fri](https://nexteralegal.com/locations/washington-dc/)
- [Miami Brickell Office (305) 686-4866 Mon–Fri](https://nexteralegal.com/locations/miami/)
